Thiol-containing metabolites are central to cellular redox homeostasis1. Among these, cysteine functions as a proteogenic amino acid, supports redox balance and iron–sulfur cluster biogenesis, and, when depleted, triggers ferroptosis2. Cells nevertheless maintain cysteine at low levels, reflecting its intrinsic toxicity, but the mechanisms by which excess cysteine causes cell death remain unclear3. Here, we performed a genome-wide CRISPR screen and identified mitochondrial iron transporters as essential mediators of cysteine toxicity. Limiting mitochondrial iron availability suppresses cysteine-induced cell death and prevents impairment of iron–sulfur cluster proteins and respiration. Mechanistically, cysteine mobilizes iron from ferritin, expands cytosolic iron pool, and drives mitochondrial iron accumulation. Enhancing glutathione reductase activity specifically within mitochondria restores redox balance downstream of iron accumulation and protects cells by maintaining iron–sulfur cluster integrity. Our findings suggest that maintaining low cysteine levels safeguards mitochondrial iron homeostasis, and that excess cysteine triggers a distinct mitochondrial iron-dependent cell death under conditions of thiol imbalance.