The mitochondrial E3 ligase MARCH5 has consistently emerged as a dependency in unbiased screens in acute myeloid leukemia and myeloma, yet the underpinning mechanism remains ill-defined. Here, we show that MARCH5 cooperates with UBE2J2 and MFN2, forming a stress-sensing complex at mitochondria–ER contact sites (MERCS) restrains apoptosis in response to diverse organellar damage signals. Loss of MARCH5 potently sensitizes diverse blood cancer cell lines to BCL-2 and BCL-XL inhibition and compromises stress tolerance. By contrast, non-hematopoietic cell lines exhibit a phenotype largely restricted to BCL-XL dependence, permitting tissue-selective therapeutic synergy with venetoclax and other agents. Mechanistically, spatial organization underpins this specificity. The complex assembles at MERCS, where it co-localizes with BCL-2 and BCL-XL but not MCL-1. Upon organellar damage, it dissociates prior to BAX/BAK activation, lowering the apoptotic threshold and enforcing reliance on neighboring BCL-2 and BCL-XL. Consistent with its distribution, MARCH5 loss minimally alters MCL-1 dependence, revealing a spatially encoded mechanism integrating diverse stress signals into cell-death decisions. To guide future therapeutics, we demonstrate that disrupting key protein–protein interactions within this complex is sufficient to sensitize blood cancer cell lines, restoring venetoclax responsiveness and prolonging survival in a murine model of refractory lymphoma. Genetic deletion of MARCH5 or UBE2J2 restored BH3-mimetic sensitivity to primary chronic lymphocytic leukemia cells rendered resistant by cytokine stimulation. These findings establish the MERCS-resident MARCH5 complex as a central regulator of malignant cell stress tolerance and highlight tractable protein interfaces for therapeutic targeting.