Protein precipitation has applications as a front-end preparation strategy for proteome analysis, as well as depleting proteins in serum for small molecule analysis or for commercial preparation of bulk protein. The highly variable conditions previously implemented to precipitate proteins are reflected by inconsistent and low recovery, as well as incomplete proteome coverage, diminishing the utility of precipitation for sample preparation. We herein investigate and optimize the conditions affecting protein recovery, using acetone at a defined ionic strength. We show rapid (2 min) precipitation at room temperature provides consistently high protein recovery (98 +/- 1%), with MS protein identifications equivalent to overnight, -20 °C incubations. Our robust strategy to isolate proteins maximizes recovery with minimal structural bias, exploiting the analytical advantages of precipitation over alternative techniques.