The R132H mutation in the metabolic enzyme isocitrate dehydrogenase 1 (IDH1) is the most important prognostic factor for survival of glioma patients. This resulted in many studies investigating the effects of this mutation, including those on energy metabolism. This led to the discovery of a panel of enzymes mainly involved in glutamate anaplerosis and aerobic glycolysis that change in abundance as a result of the IDH1 mutation. To further study these changes and investigate the therapeutic value of inhibitors of IDH1 R132H-associated metabolic pathways, appropriate glioma models are required that mimic in vivo metabolism as good as possible. To investigate how metabolism is affected by in vitro cell culture, we here compared surgically obtained snap frozen glioma tissues with their corresponding primary glioma cell culture models with a previously developed targeted mass spectrometry proteomic assay. We determined the relative abundance of a panel of metabolic enzymes. Results confirmed increased glutamate use and decreased aerobic glycolysis in resected IDH1 R132H glioma tissue samples. However, these metabolic profiles were not reflected in the paired glioma culture samples. Analysis of orthotopic glioma xenograft samples with and without the IDH1 mutation revealed metabolic profiles that more closely resembled clinical counterparts. We suggest that culture conditions and tumor microenvironment play a crucial role in maintaining the in vivo metabolic situation in cell culture models. For this reason, new models that more closely resemble the in vivo microenvironment, such as 3-dimensional cell co-cultures or organotypic multicellular spheroid models, need to be developed and investigated.